In Netflix’s comedy film Old Dads, directed by and starring stand-up comedian Bill Burr, audiences are given a humorous, sometimes outrageous look at the struggles of fatherhood in today’s rapidly evolving world. Burr, known for his brash style and candid commentary, brings his distinctive voice to the film, diving into topics of ageing, fatherhood, and cultural clashes with the newer, more progressive generation.
The film features Burr alongside actors Bobby Cannavale and Bokeem Woodbine, who, as three middle-aged fathers, find themselves navigating the challenges of parenthood, career, and staying relevant in a world that feels increasingly alien to them. This review examines the film’s successes, its pitfalls, and why it resonates with audiences, especially those grappling with similar life stages.
The Plot: Middle-Aged Fathers in a Modern World
The premise of Old Dads is straightforward: three men, all fathers in their late forties, find themselves in situations where their generational values clash with modern sensibilities. The trio faces common “older dad” challenges, like struggling with new parenting philosophies, technology-savvy children, and progressive school systems that challenge their traditional views. Much of the film’s humour and conflict centres on these generational divides, with Burr’s character, Jack, often expressing his frustration in unfiltered rants that reflect Burr’s real-life comedic style.
Jack’s friends, Connor (Bobby Cannavale) and Mike (Bokeem Woodbine) add dimension to the story as they wrestle with their own unique obstacles, from career woes to balancing fatherhood with personal insecurities. Together, they paint a vivid picture of modern fatherhood that blends laughs with a relatable dose of nostalgia. This familiar yet fresh take on the comedy genre is driven by the men’s bewilderment at society’s constant shifts and their hilarious but genuine attempts to keep up.
Bill Burr’s Comedy Style: A Love It or Hate It Approach
As the film’s writer, director, and lead, Burr infuses Old Dads with his signature humour, known for its brutally honest and often provocative edge. He addresses polarizing issues like “woke culture,” new parenting norms, and corporate conformity in a way that is unapologetically Burr. For some viewers, this is the film’s biggest draw. His rants and comedic timing deliver the kind of punch audiences expect from his stand-up shows, even though these same qualities might feel abrasive to those less familiar with or fond of his style.
However, Burr’s take-no-prisoners approach can occasionally alienate viewers who may see his humour as lacking nuance or subtlety. The comedy is raw, and while many may find it refreshing, others might feel it lacks the lightness that a broader family audience might prefer. Burr’s comedic style works for the film’s intended tone, but viewers should approach it understanding that it caters specifically to his fanbase and those who appreciate bold, irreverent humour.
The Balance of Comedy and Heart
Beyond the laughs, Old Dads aims to touch on some deeper emotional currents, particularly around fatherhood and friendship. The film manages to show how these middle-aged dads, despite their outward toughness and crass jokes, deeply care about their families. Their attempts to adapt—awkward as they may be—come from a genuine desire to connect with their children and be present as fathers. Moments when they struggle with their own insecurities or reflect on their past mistakes provide a softer, more relatable side to their characters.
The camaraderie among Jack, Connor, and Mike is another strong point. Their friendship provides a foundation that balances out the humour, reminding viewers that no matter how out of place they might feel, they’re not alone in facing these challenges. This dynamic adds layers to the story, making it more than just a series of funny, cringe-worthy moments.
Critiques: Does Old Dads Fall Short?
While Old Dads succeeds in delivering laughs and showcasing the struggles of ageing fathers, it does have its share of limitations. The film’s reliance on Burr’s intense comedic style means it sometimes misses the chance for deeper commentary on fatherhood and ageing. Some scenes feel overly reliant on stereotypes, especially regarding modern parenting techniques and the younger generation’s sensibilities, which might alienate certain audiences.
Additionally, some critics feel that the film’s narrative structure is somewhat thin, with more emphasis placed on episodic gags rather than cohesive storytelling. The focus on comedy is strong, but it sometimes sacrifices opportunities to explore the characters’ inner lives more thoroughly, making the film feel at times like a stand-up routine stitched together with a plot.
Conclusion
Old Dads is a comedy that embraces its middle-aged dad perspective with unapologetic boldness. It captures the humour, frustration, and bewilderment of fathers who suddenly find themselves “out of touch” in a rapidly changing world. Bill Burr’s characteristic style, blending humour with social commentary, will appeal to audiences who enjoy his stand-up but may not resonate with those seeking a more subtle, feel-good comedy. Nonetheless, the film brings heart to its humour, reminding us of the value of family, friendship, and the universal struggle to stay connected with the people we love.
In the end, Old Dads is a refreshingly candid take on the challenges of fatherhood, offering laughs and a nostalgic look at generational differences. It may not be everyone’s cup of tea, but for those who appreciate Burr’s humour and the struggles of modern parenthood, it delivers a memorable experience with a strong mix of comedy and sentiment.
Click here to know more.
